13 Christmas Brownie Recipes for Holiday Dessert Trays

A pan of brownies gives a Christmas dessert tray a rich chocolate starting point. Peppermint, cream cheese swirls and candy toppings add plenty of ways to make the squares feel festive.

These 13 recipes mix holiday flavors with classic brownies that fit a Christmas party. There are also individual brownie cups and one clearly labeled Irish cream option for adults.

Start with Wellness Warrior’s lower-carb brownies, then explore linked recipes from other bakers. Each card takes you to the full ingredients and instructions so you can choose the right pan, topping and prep time.

Brownies to Bake and Share at Christmas

Simple Keto Brownie Recipe (Fudgy and Chewy)

These lower-carb chocolate brownies can be cut into small squares for a holiday tray. Follow the flour and sweetener choices in the full recipe to get the intended fudgy texture.

Cookies & Cream Brownies

Brownies, cookie-studded frosting and a chocolate top make a tall layered square. They feel more like a small plated dessert than a plain snack brownie, so modest portions work well after Christmas dinner. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Seriously Fudgy Homemade Brownies

Cocoa, melted chocolate and chocolate chips give these brownies a deep chocolate flavor. Use them as the classic option on a tray that also includes mint or cream cheese varieties. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Raspberry Cheesecake Brownies

A raspberry cheesecake swirl adds a tart fruit note and a red-and-cream pattern to chocolate brownies. Their creamy topping makes a colorful choice for a chilled Christmas dessert plate. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Chewy Fudgy Frosted Brownies

A layer of chocolate frosting makes these brownies especially rich. Let both the base and topping settle as directed before slicing if you want tidy squares for a holiday platter. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Nutella Brownies

Chocolate-hazelnut spread goes into the batter and swirls over the top of these brownies. They give hazelnut fans a different choice from plain chocolate without needing a separate frosting layer. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Coconut Cheesecake Brownies

Coconut and cream cheese create a pale layer over a chocolate base. This is a useful chilled option when your Christmas dessert tray needs another flavor and texture beside mint and caramel. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Red Velvet Cheesecake Swirl Brownies

Red velvet batter and a cream cheese swirl make these brownies especially colorful for Christmas. The cocoa flavor is milder than a dark chocolate brownie, with the tangy swirl adding richness. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Peppermint Brownies

A peppermint brownie base, creamy frosting and chocolate finish make a layered holiday treat. Candy cane pieces add a little crunch, so this is a festive option when mint is the flavor you want to highlight. Recipe and photo: Holly Nilsson / Spend With Pennies.

Hot Chocolate Brownie Cups

Brownies bake in a muffin pan with a chocolate center and miniature marshmallows on top. Leave out the optional bourbon for a batch made without added liquor; their individual shape gives the platter variety. Recipe and photo: Holly Nilsson / Spend With Pennies.

Baileys Brownies

Irish cream flavors the frosting and chocolate topping on these rich brownies. These contain added alcohol, including in the topping, so keep them clearly marked as an adult dessert. Recipe and photo: Holly Nilsson / Spend With Pennies.

Candy Cane Brownies

A white frosting and crushed candy canes dress up a homemade chocolate brownie. The topping gives the tray a snowy finish with red peppermint accents, without needing careful piping or cutout shapes. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.

Caramel Bacon Brownies

Caramel, pecans and crisp bacon add a sweet-salty filling to chocolate brownies. Choose these for guests who enjoy savory notes in dessert, and label the bacon so nobody mistakes them for a meat-free treat. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.

Build a Tray with Different Textures

Choose one classic brownie and one topped or swirled version for variety. Let the pans cool before cutting, keep cream cheese varieties chilled as directed, and mark the Irish cream brownies separately.