25 Christmas Candy Recipes for Holiday Trays and Gifts

Homemade Christmas candy can be crisp, chewy, creamy or somewhere in between. A small mix of fudge, bark, toffee and dipped bites gives a holiday tray plenty of variety.

These 25 recipes include lower-carb sweets from Wellness Warrior and candies from other recipe creators. Some are quick melt-and-chill projects, while toffee and brittle need careful cooking and a ready pan.

Follow each linked recipe for the full method and storage directions. Choose gifts that suit the trip and the recipient’s storage space; a chilled cream cheese candy needs different handling from a crisp piece of brittle.

Christmas Candies to Mix and Match

Easy Keto Chocolate Fudge: A Decadent Low-Carb Treat

A lower-carb chocolate fudge gives the candy tray a rich square that is easy to portion. Use the recipe’s sweetener and allow enough refrigerator time before cutting or moving the pieces to a serving plate.

Keto Coconut Macadamia Nut Bark Recipe

Coconut and macadamias give this pale bark a nutty crunch. Because coconut oil is part of the base, keep the pieces chilled until serving rather than treating them like a firm chocolate bar.

Keto Caramel Candy Recipe

Allulose, cream and butter make a soft lower-carb caramel with a microwave method. Sweetener choice matters to the texture, and the finished pieces belong in the refrigerator or freezer as the recipe directs.

Peppermint Bark

Chocolate layers and crushed peppermint make a familiar Christmas candy. Break the set bark into pieces of different sizes for a tray, or pack it separately from soft, moist treats. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Peanut Butter Balls (Truffles)

A creamy peanut butter center gets a chocolate coating in these small candies. Chill the filling before dipping, then let the coating firm up before arranging them beside the fudge and bark. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

How to Make Oreo Balls (Truffles)

Crushed sandwich cookies and cream cheese make the centers of these chocolate-coated bites. Their dark filling and pale or dark coating bring contrast to a Christmas candy plate. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Peppermint Bark Fudge

Chocolate and white chocolate layers give this fudge the look and flavor of peppermint bark. A crushed candy cane topping adds a festive finish, with a softer bite than a piece of solid bark. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Peanut Butter Fudge

Peanut butter and powdered sugar make a creamy fudge with a microwave method. Cut it into small squares to offer a change from the chocolate-heavy parts of the Christmas candy tray. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Homemade Chocolate Truffles Recipe

Chocolate and cream make a smooth ganache center that can be rolled in different coatings. A simple cocoa or nut coating gives you variety without making a second filling. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Salted Dark Chocolate Almond Toffee

Almonds and dark chocolate finish a crisp butter toffee. This needs careful stovetop cooking rather than a quick stir-and-chill method, so give the candy stage your full attention. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

White Chocolate Caramel Cashew Clusters

Cashews, caramel and white chocolate combine in small clusters with both crunch and chew. Their pale coating brings a different look to a platter full of dark chocolate candy. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Pumpkin Spice Toffee

Pumpkin pie spice gives this crunchy toffee a warm seasonal flavor. It is a good choice for guests who prefer spice and nuts to peppermint, with a chocolate finish adding richness. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Easy Saltine Toffee (With Peanut Butter)

Saltine crackers sit under a cooked toffee layer and melted chocolate in this crisp candy. The cracker base gives it a salty bite and a different texture from traditional solid toffee. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Mint Chocolate Swirl Bark

Chocolate and mint-flavored layers swirl together in this simple-to-portion bark. Break it into pieces after it sets to add a cool flavor beside caramel and peanut butter sweets. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Reese’s Pieces Peanut Butter White Chocolate Bark

Peanut butter, white chocolate and peanut butter cup pieces make a candy-filled bark. It is a rich option for a small corner of the Christmas tray, especially for peanut butter fans. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Classic Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Chocolate-coated pretzels add a salty crunch to a Christmas candy tray. Their familiar shape gives the assortment a change from fudge squares and round truffles, with the coating left to set before packing. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.

Salted Caramel Fudge

Brown sugar and butter give this stovetop fudge a caramel flavor, with sea salt on top. It needs cooking, beating and chilling, making it a different project from a melted-chocolate fudge. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.

Cream Cheese Mints

Small cream cheese mints add a cool flavor and a soft bite to the candy assortment. Use the color options in the recipe to match a holiday plate, and follow the drying and storage directions. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.

Homemade Peppermint Patties

A smooth peppermint center sits under a chocolate shell in these homemade patties. They bring a stronger mint bite than a chocolate truffle and look neat arranged in small paper candy cups. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.

Cool Whip Candy

Whipped topping lightens a chocolate filling before it gets a firm outer coating. Plan for the freezer steps so the centers hold their shape when you dip them. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.

Microwave Peanut Brittle

Peanuts and a crisp sugar candy base make a familiar brittle with a microwave method. Have the pan and ingredients ready first, because the hot candy needs prompt handling once it is cooked. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.

Caramel Nut Brittle

A mix of nuts gives this brittle a varied crunch under a caramel-colored candy base. Break it into small pieces to serve beside softer treats rather than making every candy on the tray chewy. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.

Peppermint Crockpot Candy

A slow cooker helps melt the base for this peppermint candy before the portions are shaped and set. It gives you another way to prepare sweets while the oven is busy with Christmas baking. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.

Frito Candy

Corn chips bring a salty crunch to this sweet candy. Add it as the playful, sweet-salty option on a platter with more traditional fudge, mints and peppermint bark. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.

Pecan Pie Balls

Pecans, graham crumbs and maple flavor make small centers with a chocolate coating. They bring pecan-pie-style flavor to a candy tray without baking and slicing a full pie. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.

Pack Candies with Their Storage Needs in Mind

Mix contrasting flavors and textures, but package crisp candy separately from soft, moist treats. Check the full recipe before making a gift box, and keep refrigerated sweets chilled rather than assuming every Christmas candy can sit out.