Featured photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
A tray of Italian-inspired Christmas cookies can bring together soft citrus cookies, crisp biscotti and a little chocolate. Choose a few different textures rather than baking several batches with the same flavor.
These seven recipes include two ricotta cookies, four biscotti variations and a modern cookie inspired by spumoni. This is a small collection of Italian and Italian-inspired styles, rather than a complete guide to traditional regional Christmas baking.
Each card links to Sally’s Baking for the full recipe. Check the chilling, double-baking and chocolate-setting times before planning your baking day, especially if you are packing the cookies as gifts.
Ricotta Cookies, Biscotti and a Spumoni-Inspired Treat
Orange Chocolate Chip Ricotta Cookies
Ricotta gives these orange cookies a soft, cake-like center, with mini chocolate chips throughout. A citrus glaze finishes the tops. Plan for the dough’s chilling time before adding them to your Christmas baking day. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Lemon Ricotta Cookies
Lemon zest and juice brighten these soft ricotta cookies under a lemon glaze. They bring a lighter citrus flavor to a tray of chocolate and spice cookies, with the required dough chilling built into your schedule. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Chocolate-Dipped Almond Biscotti
Toasted almonds and brown sugar give these twice-baked cookies a nutty flavor. A chocolate dip adds a rich finish, making them a good partner for coffee after Christmas dinner. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Sweet Vanilla Bean Biscotti
Vanilla flavors these crisp biscotti, with an optional white chocolate dip for the finish. They offer a simpler flavor beside the citrus and nut versions, while keeping the familiar twice-baked crunch. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Dark Chocolate Orange Biscotti
Orange zest, walnuts and a dark chocolate coating make these biscotti a festive coffee-table choice. The dough is baked in logs, sliced and baked again, so allow time for the full process rather than treating them as quick drop cookies. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
White Chocolate Cranberry Pistachio Biscotti
Tart dried cranberries and pistachios add color and texture to these crisp cookies. White chocolate brings a sweet finish to this modern biscotti variation for a Christmas cookie tray or gift box. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Spumoni Cookies (Cherry, Pistachio, Chocolate)
Cherry, pistachio and chocolate doughs come together in a colorful marbled cookie. This is a modern cookie inspired by spumoni, rather than a claim to a traditional Italian Christmas recipe, and it gives the tray a softer alternative to biscotti. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Choose a Mix of Soft and Crisp
Pair a soft lemon or orange ricotta cookie with one biscotti flavor for a simple tray. Let glazes and chocolate coatings set fully before packing, and follow each recipe’s storage directions rather than mixing every type in one container.







