Keto Watermelon, Prosciutto and Feta Salad Recipe

The Summer Dish That Shouldn’t Work… But Totally Does

Some recipes just shouldn’t make sense. Watermelon in a keto dish? With feta cheese? And salty prosciutto on top? Sounds weird—until you taste it. Then you’re wondering where it’s been all your life.

This salad is cold, salty, sweet, creamy and crunchy all in one bite. And weirdly enough, it works. It more than works. It hits every single craving at once.

But here’s the thing most blogs don’t tell you…

Yes, watermelon has sugar. But in small amounts, it’s actually one of the lowest-carb fruits you can eat. Mix it with high-fat, low-carb stuff like feta, olive oil and salty prosciutto, and boom: you’ve got a keto-friendly salad that feels like cheating—but isn’t.

So, whether you’re new to keto or just bored of bacon and eggs, this one’s worth trying.

Let’s break it down, then I’ll show you how to make it, how to store it, what to avoid, and a few personal flops that I turned into wins. I’ll also show you how to serve it depending on who’s coming over—kids, picky adults, full keto crowd or not.

First off, what’s in it?

The basic ingredients:

• Watermelon (just a little)
• Prosciutto
• Feta cheese
• Arugula or spinach (or both)
• Olive oil
• Fresh lime or lemon juice
• Cracked black pepper
• Optional: avocado, cucumber, mint, pumpkin seeds

Simple, right? But the combo is a total flavor bomb.

The fat from the prosciutto and feta balances out the natural sugar in the watermelon. The greens give you crunch, the lime makes it pop, and olive oil ties it all together.

But is watermelon even keto?

Fair question. Most keto folks avoid fruit like it’s the plague. But here’s what’s true:

Watermelon has about 11 grams of carbs per cup. But we’re not eating cups of it here. You’re using a few small chunks across the whole salad. Split between 2–4 people? That’s barely 2–3 net carbs each.

If you stay under your daily carb target (usually 20–50 grams), a little watermelon fits fine—especially if the rest of your plate is loaded with fat and protein.

So yes, watermelon can be keto. It’s all about portion and what you pair it with.

Prep: what actually works

Here’s how I make this salad at home, step-by-step.

Ingredients 

• 1 heaping cup diced watermelon (seedless, cold)
• 4–6 slices prosciutto (torn or sliced)
• 1/2 cup crumbled feta cheese
• 2 big handfuls of arugula or spinach
• Juice of 1/2 lime (or lemon if that’s all you’ve got)
• 1 tablespoon good olive oil
• Black pepper to taste

Optional extras that totally level it up:

• 1/2 an avocado, diced
• A few thin cucumber slices
• Fresh mint leaves
• Roasted pumpkin seeds for crunch

How To Make This Watermelon and Prosciutto Salad

1) Prep the greens:

Start by rinsing your arugula or spinach under cold water to get rid of any dirt or grit. Use a salad spinner if you’ve got one, or gently pat the greens dry with a clean kitchen towel or paper towels. The drier, the better—wet greens will make your salad soggy fast.

2) Chop the watermelon:

Slice off the rind and cut the watermelon into small, bite-sized cubes—nothing too big or juicy. If it’s overly watery, let the pieces rest on a paper towel for a minute or two to soak up the extra juice. You’re looking for crisp, clean cubes that add sweetness without flooding the bowl.

3) Tear the prosciutto:

Take each slice and gently tear it into long, uneven ribbons. Don’t chop it with a knife—torn pieces give better texture and a more rustic look. Plus, it stops it from clumping together in the salad.

4) Layer the salad:

In a large salad bowl or serving platter, add your dried greens as the base. Scatter the watermelon cubes evenly across the top. Then place the torn prosciutto over everything, making sure it’s not all clumped in one spot. Crumble the feta over last, letting it fall naturally so you get some in every bite.

5) Dress it lightly:

Drizzle olive oil evenly over the top of the salad. Squeeze half a lime or lemon over everything (watch out for seeds). Finish with a few cracks of fresh black pepper. No need for salt—feta and prosciutto have that covered.

6) Serve it how you like:

If you’re serving it immediately and want everything evenly coated, you can gently toss the salad once or twice with clean hands or salad tongs. If you’re going for looks (and impressing guests), just leave it layered and untouched, it looks more elegant that way.

Done. That’s it.

Takes about 10 minutes total. No cooking. No fancy tools. Just one bowl and one sharp knife.

Taste profile: what it’s like

This salad is salty from the prosciutto and feta. The watermelon cuts through with sweet and juicy bites. The arugula gives a peppery note, while olive oil and lime keep it fresh and clean.

It’s kinda like a cold pizza without the crust. All the flavor, none of the carb bomb.

If you’ve ever had melon and prosciutto on an antipasto plate, this is like that—but turned into an actual dish.

Tips from trial and error

I’ve made this salad more times than I can count. Some versions were great. Some, not so much.

Here’s what I learned:

Don’t add salt.

I know, I know—it’s a salad. But between the feta and prosciutto, it’s already salty enough. Add more and it starts tasting like seawater.

Use cold watermelon.

Room-temp watermelon makes everything soggy. Chill it first. Bonus if you use a melon baller and freeze the balls for 10 minutes. Texture game-changer.

Don’t overdress.

Too much lime or oil makes everything slide around and get slimy. A light drizzle is enough.

Don’t toss if serving later.

If you’re prepping ahead, keep the greens separate. Toss it all together right before eating or it wilts and loses that fresh crunch.

Storage and leftovers

Here’s the honest truth: this salad does not keep well.

The watermelon leaks juice and turns the greens to mush if it sits too long. But if you keep everything separate and only mix when you’re ready to eat, you can store it for up to 2 days.

Here’s how I store it:

• Greens in one container
• Watermelon and feta in another (drain off any juice)
• Prosciutto wrapped in paper towel so it stays dry
• Dressing (oil and lime) in a small jar

Then just mix when ready. Perfect for work lunch or quick dinner.

Keto swaps and personal tweaks

Want more fat?

Add half an avocado. Or double the feta. Or drizzle a little more olive oil. I’ve even added bacon bits before. Not traditional, but it slaps.

Hate arugula?

Use spinach. Or a mix of both. I even used romaine once when I was out of greens and it worked surprisingly well.

Need to stretch it?

Add grilled chicken on top. Makes it a full meal, not just a side. I do this when I’m feeding my husband because “salad isn’t dinner” apparently.

Who actually likes this Keto Watermelon and Prosciutto Salad?

I’ve served this salad to:

• My keto best friend (she asked for the recipe)
• My carb-loving sister (she didn’t even notice it was keto)
• My five-year-old (he picked out the watermelon and feta, but hey, still counts)
• A barbecue crowd with burgers and ribs (it vanished fast)

It’s one of those weird dishes that works with different people for different reasons. Some like the sweet, some love the salt. And if you plate it right, it looks fancy even though it’s dead simple.

Can you make it fancy for guests?

Absolutely. Here’s what I do when trying to impress:

• Use a big white platter instead of a bowl
• Ball the watermelon instead of dicing it
• Layer everything like a chopped Caprese salad
• Scatter mint leaves and pumpkin seeds on top
• Serve with chilled forks (yes, that’s a thing—try it)

Boom. Pinterest-worthy without lifting much more than a finger.

Carb count (approximate)

• Watermelon (1 cup): ~11g carbs
• Feta (1/2 cup): ~2g
• Greens (2 cups): ~1–2g
• Prosciutto: 0g
• Lime juice: ~1g
• Olive oil: 0g

Rough total per serving (divided into 3): 5–6g net carbs

Perfect for keto or low-carb eaters. Plus it actually fills you up.

Why this recipe actually works for keto

Keto isn’t just about eating bacon and butter. It’s about balance. You need fiber. You need some crunch, some freshness, something that isn’t all grease.

This salad gives you:

• Natural sweetness, without spiking blood sugar
• A hit of fat and protein to keep you full
• Salt and acid to wake up your taste buds
• And real satisfaction from something that’s not a “keto version” of something else

No fake ingredients. No artificial sweeteners. Just real food, smart portions, and flavor that holds up.

Conclusion

You know when you eat the same 3 things over and over on keto and your brain gets bored before your stomach?

This salad fixes that.

It’s quick, cheap, and feels like you’re eating something normal. Something that belongs at a picnic or Sunday lunch. Not just another pile of meat and eggs.

I’ve taken this to park days, wrapped it up for lunch, even made it with leftover rotisserie chicken once and called it dinner.

It works. And if you’re even thinking about skipping it because of the watermelon, give it one shot. You might be surprised what a couple bites can do.

Let me know how it turns out. And if you try your own version—say, goat cheese instead of feta, or adding grilled shrimp—send that too. I’m always on the lookout for easy wins.

Just no raisins. We have standards.

Print