A good pie makes a lovely finish to Christmas dinner, whether you prefer flaky pastry, creamy filling or a nutty slice with a little crunch. You do not need to make every kind to give guests a choice.
These 17 recipes include lower-carb pies from Wellness Warrior, familiar baked favorites and chilled cream pies. The methods range from rolled pastry to simple batter-based pies, with different cooling and setting times.
Start with the two Wellness Warrior recipes, then browse ideas from other bakers. Every card links to the full recipe so you can check the ingredients, pan and make-ahead steps before choosing your Christmas dessert.
Pies to Serve After Christmas Dinner
Keto Sugar-Free Pecan Pie That’ll Rock Your Holiday Table
Toasted pecans and a buttery filling sit in an almond-flour crust in this lower-carb pie. Follow the sweetener recommendation in the recipe, since it affects both the filling and the texture after chilling.
Keto Meringue Pie Recipe – Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth!
A lemon filling and a pale meringue top give this lower-carb pie a bright flavor. The almond-flour crust is baked before filling, with a final oven step to brown the meringue.
The Great Pumpkin Pie Recipe
Pumpkin and warm spices make a familiar pie for the Christmas dessert table. The recipe includes sugared cranberries and pastry leaves for a festive finish, with enough cooling time needed before slicing. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Apple Cranberry Crumble Pie
Tart cranberries add bright color and flavor to an apple filling under an oat crumble. Choose it when you want a fruit pie with a crisp topping rather than a second layer of pastry. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
French Silk Pie
A smooth chocolate filling and whipped cream make this a rich chilled pie. The full recipe walks through cooking the egg mixture and building the filling, so read the method before planning it as a quick dessert. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Butterscotch Pie
Brown sugar and a creamy cooked filling give this pie its butterscotch flavor. It is a good change from chocolate or fruit pies when you want a sweet, buttery slice after Christmas dinner. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Homemade Coconut Cream Pie
Coconut milk and shredded coconut flavor a custard filling under whipped cream. This is a chilled cream pie, with a fully baked crust and time in the refrigerator before serving. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Cookies & Cream Pie (Oreo)
Cookie crumbs form the crust around a creamy filling with more cookie pieces. It gives the Christmas dessert table a familiar cookies-and-cream option without making a full cheesecake. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Homemade Banana Cream Pie
Bananas layer with a homemade vanilla custard in a baked crust, finished with whipped cream. Add it to a dessert spread when you want a fruit flavor that is softer and creamier than an apple pie. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Nutella Cream Pie
Chocolate-hazelnut spread gives this creamy pie a rich filling under a chocolate finish. The recipe includes optional hazelnut liqueur; leave it out if serving guests who want a dessert made without added liquor. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Unbelievable Peanut Butter Pie
A peanut butter filling and chocolate ganache sit over a dark cookie crust. Small slices work well after a large Christmas meal, especially if guests are choosing more than one dessert. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Classic Apple Pie
A generous apple filling bakes between two layers of pastry in this classic pie. Cinnamon and other warm spices make it a familiar choice beside richer Christmas cream and chocolate desserts. Recipe and photo: Sally McKenney / Sally’s Baking.
Impossible Eggnog Pie
Eggnog, nutmeg and cinnamon give this pie a clear Christmas flavor. Baking mix goes into the batter rather than a separate rolled crust, making it a different method from a traditional pastry pie. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.
Old-Fashioned Maple Syrup Pie
Maple syrup and brown sugar give this baked custard pie a deep sweetness. A simple slice with whipped cream or ice cream makes a warming finish to a holiday dinner. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.
Impossible Buttermilk Pie
Buttermilk, vanilla and a little lemon flavor this softly set pie. The baking mix is part of the batter, so there is no separate pastry crust to roll out. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.
Coconut Pie
Shredded coconut bakes into a sweet filling in a pastry shell. It has a different texture from coconut cream pie, making it a useful choice for guests who prefer a baked coconut dessert. Recipe and photo: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie.
Choose a Pie That Fits Your Schedule
Pair a rich chocolate or nut pie with a fruit or lemon option if you want variety. Leave room for cooling and chilling, and check the optional liqueur in the Nutella pie when planning for guests who avoid added alcohol.

















